Andrew Jefford: Pale lemon-gold. Fresh, light, sweet, unfocused. Pleasant but not magnetic. Another deeply and vividly fruity wine, with lots of quivering apple and whitecurrant freshness. Some minerals to finish. Pure and intense; will give much pleasure. 15.5

Simon Larkin : Similar hue. Exotic fruit aromas: pearskin, pineapple, as well as lime and green apple. The fruit here is quite lifted, with an almost shrill acid underscoring the barely ripe green-apple fruit. Lively, clean, with good persistence. A sound example, once more adding to the mediocrity of this style. 12.5

Alexander Scott: This is really remarkably similar to the Christman Konigsbacher Idig but has more energy and penetration on the palate. This is fine wine with some future - it might develop more complexity with 5 years in bottle. 15