Michael Edwards: Soft flavors, a touch lactic. Medium weight, with a surprisingly persistent finish 15.5

Simon Field: Gentle color and elegant citric nose; spring flowers and hints of chalk; the palate is focused, very precise in its linear authority and with the confidence of strong youth. A southern style with the self-discipline of a victor ludorum 17

Tom Stevenson: Obviously complex but does little to invite, yet it has the acidity to develop. Best advice would be to leave for a year or two 16