Michel Bettane and Thierry Desseauve | Pale color, astonishing aromatic freshness, huge finesse, great length; impeccable balance, great future; a masterful wine. | 17.5

Michael Schuster | Dumb still to smell; elegant, concentrated, vital wine; intensely sweet, rich, silky textured, long to taste, long to finish, with clear botrytis concentration, spice, and complexity. Lovely, and very successful. | 17