Michel Bettane: Great color, magnificent body, huge texture from old vines; noble tannins; great wine up to the best second growths. 18

Thierry Desseauve: Toasty but flowery nose, super noble and silky tannins, great length, perfect balance. A top wine of the vintage. 18.5

Michael Schuster: Youthful, densely fruited nose; generous, elegant, richly fruited but also tannic St-Pierre; abundantly flavored, long and loose-grained, with excellent fruit length; a really fine, long-term St-Julien. 2024–35+. 17.5