Gerard Basset: Medium-light green-yellow. Ripe but not overly expressive, fruit masked by SO2 at the moment. Ripe texture, moderate retro-olfaction, medium-short finish. 12.5
Marcel Orford-Williams: Lacks cut, really. Sweet and not crisp. 11
Roy Richards: SO2 on the nose, but on the palate perhaps the best Muscat in terms of balance. None of them is, however, dramatically exciting. 13
Details
Wine expert | Roy Richards Marcel Orford-Williams Gerard Basset |
Tastings year | 2005 |
Region | Alsace |
Appellation | AOC |