Gerard Basset: Medium silver-yellow. Very mineral, with some white truffle. Tight structure, herbal tea in retro-olfaction, medium-long finish. 15.5
Marcel Orford-Williams: Very high-toned in its flavours of quince. Some sweetness here still. Nice balance. 15
Roy Richards: This has no interest left and I love old wines in general. Clapped out. 10
Details
| Wine expert | Roy Richards Marcel Orford-Williams Gerard Basset |
| Tastings year | 2005 |
| Region | Alsace |
| Appellation | AOC - Grand Cru |
Domaine Ostertag

