Michael Edwards: Rather a clumsy wine; ripe (almost overripe) fruit and a jarring acidity, illustrative of the problems with 2005 13
Simon Field: Slightly oxidative nose, perhaps not completely clean. Palate is a little flat and lackluster, failing to impress 12
Tom Stevenson: Lacks fruit, yet has richness. Bitterness on the finish 10
Details
| Wine expert | Michael Edwards Simon Field Tom Stevenson |
| Tastings year | 2012 |
| Region | Champagne |
| Appellation | Champagne AOC |






