Michel Bettane: Pale for a young Guiraud, very elegant, fully preserved from any oxidation, evident noble rot, great length: superb. 18

Thierry Desseauve: Gold but young color, subtle notes of lime-tree honey, smooth body, harmonious length, perfect balance, with a great freshness. 18.5

Michael Schuster: Deepish gold; closed but lightly oak-marked nose; rich and concentrated, with adequate acidity; rich, broad, intensely sweet flavor, generous, juicy, lightly oaky, with a fine Botrytis complexity, long to taste, long and spicily aromatic to finish. Now to 2035+. 17+