Essi Avellan | Deep cherry-toned color. Smoky layers over rich, sweet Pinot fruit. Straightforward fruity style, with cherry confiture and strawberry. Needs finesse and complexity. Structured, with some phenolics. | 87

Simon Field | Extravagant magenta, soft-peach color and a nose of fireworks, wild strawberry, and verbena; come-hither palate, with wild strawberries, citron, and blueberry; all pleasingly integrated, pleasingly resonant, and with great potential. | 90

Anthony Rose | A light cherryish color; a fine raspberryish aroma supported by complexing lees-aged notes, this is delicately fruity on the palate, with a lively raspberryish quality and an underlying complexity, all finely textured and extremely well rendered in a convincing, dry rosé Champagne. | 91