Andrew Jefford | Pale silver-straw in color. Lively, vivid, fresh, with orchard fruits (apple and pear) sent into a sweet curve but without any notable spice or floral notes. Could almost be a Chenin Blanc. This is (for me) true of the palate, too: It’s generous, well rounded, and sweet, given life and dignity by its orchard fruits, but with many fewer Gewurztraminer keys than its peers. Still a very good wine and a wonderful drink. Perhaps a question of site? | 90

Charles Metcalfe | Rather lean and reductive, with some lemony aroma. The palate is also tucked up and waiting, with lemony acidity, ripe honeyed fruit, and quite a lot of sugar. This needs time to get to a more drinkable stage. | 88

Jancis Robinson | Bright deep straw. Light, rather simple nose. Sweet and round, with some Gewurz-in-a-cloud. Hint of red pepper. But not enough acidity, alas— despite the good grip on the end. Quite fresh. Drink 2017–20. | 89