Andrew Jefford: Relatively pale gold. Slightly mucky nose; some attempts at rose charm but muddled, and there is also some grubbiness. Full fruited, deep, yet lacking in cleanliness and charm. 11

Simon Larkin : Appearance: no vast differences to speak of. Some impurity on the nose is suggested. Musky, peachy fruit. Biting green fruit on the palate and modest definition. Lively acidity and few bold statements. A shame, because the sherbetty apple notes are quite appealing. The overall impression is of a disjointed wine. 11

Alexander Scott: Very similar to the Nierstein Orbel, but a bit broader and gentler. This will be a very enjoyable glass of wine in three years. It has the feel of a top-class vineyard site. 15.5