Michael Edwards: Generous, ripe; even a touch of vanilla au nez. Brisk and vital, the flavors variegated. Acceptable 15
Simon Field: Reticent nose, with a stone-fruit persona and hints of tobacco box. The palate is bigger, sweeter than expected, quite raw and lacking requisite harmony for its perceived pedigree 14.5
Tom Stevenson: Rather rustic orchard fruits; not the best 2006 10
Details
| Wine expert | Michael Edwards Simon Field Tom Stevenson |
| Tastings year | 2012 |
| Region | Champagne |
| Appellation | Champagne AOC |






