Stephen Brook: Very discreet nose, pink grapefruit. Quite rich and broad, so much so that it lacks zest. Solid, with ample grapefruity acidity but not enough overt fruitiness to surmount it. It's not bad, but it's lacklustre. Moderate length. 13

Jancis Robinson: Hint of mousiness (sulphur?) on the nose. Not 100 per cent clean or fresh, and rather heavy and foot-dragging on the palate. 12

Alexander Scott: Undistinguished nose; slightly sour-toned palate, though with reasonable vigour. Not bad. 11