Gerard Basset: Light green-yellow. SO2 at first. Quite mineral at aeration. Ripe structure, baked fruit in retro-olfaction, medium finish. 13.5
Marcel Orford-Williams: Sulphur on nose. Full flavour. Basic material is good but hampered by the appearance of high sulphur. Lacks brilliance. 13.5
Roy Richards: Reductive: burnt notes and SO2 - this also dominates palate, making it a bit unclean. Not its day. Tried another bottle: the same. 10
Details
Wine expert | Roy Richards Marcel Orford-Williams Gerard Basset |
Tastings year | 2005 |
Region | Alsace |
Appellation | AOC |