Gerard Basset: Silver green-yellow. Very appealing orange flower. Lively and juicy, excellent balance, medium -long finish. 16

Marcel Orford-Williams: Discreet, more Ottonel than Muscat d ’Alsace maybe. Some depth and flavour, but a bit sweet and simple. Clean, though, and not unpleasant - but not me. 12.5

Roy Richards: A rather restrained nose, grapey, but not in your face. Sweet, a scrape of SO2 in back palate. Simple. Pas plus que ça. 12