Gerard Basset: Medium-deep young gold. Very candied fruit with some dried flowers. Lively structure with some candied grapefruit in retro-olfaction, medium-long finish. 15
Marcel Orford-Williams: There is some quality here, but the finish is poor and charm less. Seems old before its time, too. 11
Roy Richards: Powerful nose, lime and ginger. Latter very prominent. Some CO2 on the palate. This is a powerhouse, with good acidity and no excess alcohol. Exciting. 17
Details
Wine expert | Roy Richards Marcel Orford-Williams Gerard Basset |
Tastings year | 2005 |
Region | Alsace |
Appellation | AOC |