Stephen Brook: Rich appley nose, withatouch of honey and caramel. Rounded, supple, ripe apples, fairly sweet, silky texture, attractive, with delicate underlying acidity that keeps the palate lively. Quite good length. 16.5

Andrew Jefford: Distinctive Nahe-like nose, which hints as much at new leaf and linden blossom as to pressed summer fruits: enticing and complex. A well-structured wine with palpable minerality. Deep, long, complex, with well-judged balance of ripe acidity, earth and vivid orchard fruit; not too much idle sugar, either. Memorable. 16.5

Jancis Robinson: Broad, natural yeast aroma with great spread of complex aromas. Still some sulphur. Sweetness hits the front palate and there is less body than the nose suggests. Quite delicate. Correct and relatively restrained. Drink 2007-13.16